Money
Management is a weekly column on personal finance prepared and
distributed by certified public accountants.
FOR
IMMEDIATE RELEASE: July 11, 2005
COVERDELL
ACCOUNT OR 529 PLAN: A SIDE-BY-SIDE COMPARISON
Higher
education is one of the largest financial expenses facing families
today. Parents and family members who are saving for a child’s
education should learn all they can about Section 529 College
Savings Plans and Coverdell Education Savings Accounts (formerly
Education IRAs). While both offer significant tax benefits, they
differ in other respects. Here, the New York State Society of
CPAs present a comparison that can assist you in making the investment
choice that works best for you.
TAX
CONSIDERATIONS
While
contributions to a Section 529 Plan or a Coverdell Education Savings
Account are not federally tax deductible, earnings grow tax free,
significantly increasing total returns. Some states offer tax
deductions and other benefits for residents who contribute to
their home state 529 Plan.
As
long as the money is used for qualified educational expenses,
withdrawals from both Coverdell Accounts and 529 Plans are free
from federal (and often state) income taxes.
CONTRIBUTION
LIMITS
Parents,
grandparents, relatives, and friends can contribute to a beneficiary’s
Coverdell Account or Section 529 Plan. For a Coverdell Account,
the maximum annual contribution is $2,000 per beneficiary from
all contributors combined, making it difficult to accumulate a
sufficient amount of money unless you start early. There are income
limits, as well. Contributions to a Coverdell are gradually phased
out when the contributor’s modified adjusted gross income
is between $95,000 and $110,000 on a single return and between
$190,000 and $220,000 for married couples filing jointly.
In
contrast, Section 529 Plans allow dramatically higher contributions
– in excess of $200,000 in many states – and there
are no income eligibility limits.
INVESTMENT
CHOICES
Whichever
you select, choosing the right investment mix is important for
reaching your long-term college savings goal. When it comes to
investing, Coverdell Accounts and 529 plans invested through your
broker offer greater flexibility, since you direct the investment
strategy and can invest your contributions in your choice of stocks,
bonds, and mutual funds.
While
states are beginning to offer more investment options, investing
in a state 529 Plan typically means choosing from one or more
investment portfolios offered by the plan you select. You can
switch investment tracks or roll your savings over into another
state’s plan once a year without penalty.
HOW
PROCEEDS CAN BE USED
The
money you have invested in a Section 529 Plan can be used for
qualified college education costs –- tuition, room and board,
books, and transportation –- at any accredited college in
the United States. There’s no rush to use the money because,
in most states, there is no age limit for applying the funds to
qualified educational costs.
If
the beneficiary of a 529 Plan decides not to go to college, the
invested funds can be transferred to another member of the beneficiary’s
immediate family -- including first cousins -- and used for their
qualified educational expenses.
Coverdell
Accounts offer you more flexibility in how you spend the money.
Families can use the money in a Coverdell Account to pay for any
level of education, including elementary and secondary school
costs, and even academic tutoring and education-related computer
expenses.
However,
you should be aware that the Coverdell is considered a custodial
account, which means that the beneficiary becomes the legal account
owner when he or she reaches the age of majority (18 or 21, depending
on the state you live in). As account owner, the beneficiary can
use the funds in any way he or she chooses, and bear the tax consequences.
Unused
funds in a Coverdell Account can be rolled over, without penalty,
to other family members under age 30.
IMPACT
ON FINANCIAL AID
For
purposes of obtaining student financial aid, Coverdell Education
Accounts and 529 Plans receive equal treatment in the calculation
of federal financial aid eligibility. Both are regarded as assets
of the parent, rather than the student.
MAKING
A CHOICE
Deciding
whether to open a Coverdell Account, a 529 College Plan, or both,
is an important one. Consult with a CPA who can review your financial
situation and help you determine which savings strategy is best
for you.
#
# #
PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT
GET THE FACTS ABOUT COVERDELL EDUCATION SAVINGS ACCOUNTS AND SECTION
529 SAVINGS PLANS
Approximate
Length: 60 seconds
When
saving for college is a priority, it’s wise to consider
all options, including section 529 Plans and Coverdell Education
Savings Accounts –- formally education IRAs. Contributions
in both types of plans grow tax free and withdrawals are free
from federal income taxes as long as the money is used for qualified
educational expenses.
Generally,
individuals may be able to save more money in Section 529 plans
than Coverdell Accounts. That is because the maximum annual contribution
to a Coverdell Account is $2,000 per beneficiary from all contributors
combined and contributions are gradually phased out when the contributor’s
modified adjusted gross income reaches certain limits. Section
529 Plans allow dramatically higher contributions –- in
excess of $200,000 in many states –- and there are no income
eligibility limits.
However,
Coverdell Accounts offer you more flexibility on how you spend
the money. Families can use the money in a Coverdell Account to
pay for any level of education, including elementary and secondary
school costs, and even academic tutoring and education-related
computer expenses. More restrictions apply to Section 529 plans.
To
determine which plan savings vehicle will help you to meet your
goals, contact your CPA.