Want to save this page for later?

Peer Review

Prospective Firms

I. AICPA Peer Review
The AICPA requires its member firms to undergo a peer review every three years. Information specific to AICPA can be found here.

II. Mandatory Peer Review in NYS

CPA firms that provide attest services in New York State must undergo peer review every three years and submit copies of the report and acceptance letter to the New York State Education Department. 

For further information, visit the Society’s Mandatory Peer Review FAQs page. The NYSSCPA’s peer review technical manager provides an overview of peer and answers some pertinent questions for firms within the scope of the new regulations.

For further information from the New York State Education Department, visit the Mandatory Peer Review page on the SED website or the Mandatory Peer Review section of the Accountancy Regulations.

III. Register for Peer Review with NYSSCPA

To register for Peer Review with the NYSSCPA, please visit http://www.aicpa.org/InterestAreas/PeerReview/Pages/PRIMA.aspx. PRIMA launched Monday, May 1, 2017. Firms attempting to enroll in peer review can log into PRIMA at: prima.aicpa.org. For an FAQ and more information, see AICPA.org/PRIMA.

To create a new firm for purposes of registering in the peer review program, use the Public Accounting Firm Creation Form. Please click here.


IV. Firm Registration

If your firm provides attest or compilation services to New York State clients, or uses “CPA,” “Certified Public Accountants,” “PA,” or “Public Accountants in your firm name, you are required to register as a public accounting firm with the New York State Education Department.

Public Accounting Firm Registration FAQs

Form 6R. Application for Public Accounting Firm Registration (For Firms Other Than Professional Corporations). This form must be completed by the CPA or PA responsible for this firm.

V. Finding a Peer Reviewer

Looking for a reviewer? Search here

VI. Peer Review Rates

Peer Review Rates: (Effective June 1, 2017 – May 31, 2018)

The annual administrative fee is levied on program enrollees to cover the costs of administering the AICPA Peer Review Program (PRP) and Mandatory Quality Review in New York State.  According to AICPA PRP guidelines, all costs of the administrative agents, such as administrative and technical review of peer reviews, required program oversight procedures, and reviewer resume and CPE verification, are to be borne by the firms that participate in the PRP. 

Formula

(Fee = Base Charge + Review Type, Firm Size and any non-member surcharges. Fee is capped)

Base Charge

 

$164

Review Type

 

 

 

System Review

$247

 

Engagement Review

$105

Firm Size Charge

 

 

 

Sole Practitioner

$0

 

2-5

$76

 

6-10

$196

 

11-19

$410

 

20-49

$1098

 

50-99

$3030

 

100+

$3850

Non-Member Surcharge

 

25%

No A&A Practice

 

 

 

NYSSCPA Member

$25

 

Non-NYSSCPA Member

$31

Cap (Maximum Due)

 

$2330

First-Time Enrollment Fee

 

$75


Additional Fees:

AICPA National Peer Review Annual Administrative Fee 


Other Fees - Effective June 1, 2016

  • Reinstatement Fee: Firms that re-enroll after resigning or being dropped/terminated from the peer review program will be charged a$300 reinstatement fee(in addition to back fees for all missed years).
  • Replacement Review Fee: In the event of the need to recall any peer review’s previously issued acceptance letter and that requires the firm to have a replacement review performed as part of recall procedures, the affected firm will be charged a $375 replacement fee at the time of recall to defray additional associated costs.
  • High-Risk Engagement Surcharge:This will be $125 per high-risk engagement, up to 3 engagements (fee is capped at $375).  The surcharge is the result of increased regulatory oversight of high-risk industries related to the peer review program. This will be billed separately and only in the year of your firm’s peer review.

VII. Peer Review Staff

Questions about the NYSSCPA Peer Review Program, contact the peer review staff below

Ernie Markezin

Director, Professional & Technical Resources

ejmarkezin@nysscpa.org

212-719-8303

Mark Rachleff

Manager, Peer Review Technical

mrachleff@nysscpa.org

212-719-8401

Theresa Campbell

Manager, Peer Review Administration

tcampbell@nysscpa.org

212-719-8435

Sobeida Cortorreal

Peer Review Admin.

scortorreal@nysscpa.org

212-719-8372

Sandia Raghubir

Peer Review Admin

sraghubir@nysscpa.org

212-719-8406

 

To register your firm for Peer Review with the NYSSCPA complete this enrollment form


Firm Enrollment Form