| |
|
Governance
| MINUTES
OF: |
FAE
Board of Trustees Meeting |
| DATE
OF MEETING: |
Friday,
September 20, 2002 |
| PLACE
OF MEETING: |
The
Desmond Hotel, Albany, NY |
| TIME
MEETING CONVENED: |
1:00
p.m. |
| TIME
MEETING ADJOURNED: |
4:45 p.m. |
| PRESIDING
OFFICER: |
Nancy
Newman-Limata, President |
| TRUSTEES
PRESENT: |
Jeffery
R, Hoops, Secretary
Illene L. Persoff*
Jo Ann Golden, President-Elect
Thomas E. Riley
Katherine K. Doran
Diane M. Wiktorowski*
Sharon Sabba Fierstein*
Louis Grumet, Executive Director |
| MEMBER
ABSENT: |
Ronald
Benjamin |
| STAFF
PRESENT: |
Lynn
T. Chambers
Annette Davis
Alan Schmelkin
Annette Davis
William Pape*
James Woehlke*
|
| OTHERS
PRESENT: |
Ann
Cohen (President, Buffalo Chapter)*
Robert Eckert (Past President, Westchester Chapter)*
Steven Kaplan (President, Rockland Chapter)*
Robert Sypolt (President, Queens Chapter)*
|
*Participated
by Conference Call
Minutes
Open
Discussion on Chapter CPE:
Before
the meeting was called for order, NYSSCPA President Jo Ann
Golden gave a background report on the issue of the Westchester
Chapter requesting to charge a lower fee (current fee $150)
for chapter full-day conferences. She noted that the issue
surfaced earlier this year and a meeting was held with Westchester
Chapter President Susan Schoenfeld to discuss and review
the related overhead costs and staff time allocated to administering
chapter programs. Ms. Golden stated that at the July 2002
Annual Leadership Conference, Chapter Vice President Laurence
Keiser held a meeting with chapter presidents regarding
the matter.
Ms.
Golden reported that the Westchester Chapter was authorized
to charge a lower fee of $95 for a full day conference last
year, provided that the chapter gain sponsorship of $5,000
to supplement the full registration fee of $150. It was
announced that the Westchester has again requested a lower
fee of $99 as a discount for early registration while keeping
the $125 for the regular price for an upcoming conference
in December. The chapter was directed to seek sponsorship
to supplement the balance of the standard $150 registration
fee.
It
was noted that, once determined, a standard price should
be set for all chapter full day and half-day conferences.
Following discussion, it was suggested that the formula
for establishing a price for chapter programs should be
a per participant overhead cost. Director of Education Alan
Schmelkin reported that he had prepared a summary of the
overhead cost of staff time associated with all event programming,
which resulted in $168 per hour, as an average cost of overhead.
Following discussion, President Newman-Limata recommended
that a task force be created to study the expense history
of the prior year. It was also recommended that, with the
exception of the Westchester Chapter pre-approved reduced
registration fee, all chapter will continue to charge the
current standard registration fee of $150 for full day chapter
conferences until a new policy is established.
| 0)
Call to Order |
President
Newman-Limata called the meeting to order, recognizing
Trustees Fierstein, Persoff and Wiktorowski joining
the meeting by
conference call at 1:00 p.m.
|
| 1)
Approval of President |
Newman-Limata
asked for a motion to approve the
Minutes minutes for the meeting held on July 14, 2002.
Mr. Riley moved
and Jo Ann Golden seconded a motion to approve the
minutes as
written. Ms. Wiktorowski asked that the minutes be
corrected to
reflect that she serves on the executive board of
the Buffalo
Chapter. Following discussion, the motion was unanimously
approved with correction noted.
|
| 2)
POP Program for 2002-03 |
President Newman-Limata asked Alan Schmelkin to give
a report
on the POP program. Mr. Schmelkin reported that 585
POP books were sold resulting in sales totaled $838,155
for fiscal year 2001/2002. He recommended the continuation
of the POP program for 2002/2003 effective September
1, 2002 with a proposed reduced pricing as follows:
Type
of POP Book |
Proposed Pricing |
| |
Early
Bird |
Regular |
| Member
Individual |
$
995 |
$1,095 |
| Non
Member Individual |
1,499 |
1,595 |
| Firm
Booklet |
1,495 |
1,595 |
Mr.
Schmelkin reported that the amount of $225, 297 of
the
total POP sales was left available in POP deferred
revenue at
August 31, 2002. Anticipating a similar usage pattern
for next
year’s sales and the psychological benefit of
ticket purchases of
under $1,000, he proposed that the Trustees consider
the $100
reduction off last year’s pricing.
President
Newman-Limata requested that a study be done to
analyze the overall cost of the POP program. She further
suggested that the POP program should be aggressively
marketed
to firms. Following further discussion, Jo Ann Golden
made a
motion to accept the proposed pricing for the POP
program. The
motion was defeated with 5 opposing and 3 in favor
of the proposed pricing. As a result of the vote,
the current pricing of the POP program and all POP
regulations will remain as follows effective September
1, 2002 through August 31, 2003, with an Early Bird
cut off date of November 30, 2002:
Type
of POP Book |
Current Pricing |
| |
Early
Bird |
Regular |
| Member
Individual |
$1,095 |
$1,195 |
| Non
Member Individual |
1,599 |
1,695 |
| Firm
Booklet |
1,595 |
1,695 |
|
| 3)
FAE Technology Task Force Update |
President
Newman-Limata asked Mr. Schmelkin to give an update
on the Technology Task Force activity. Mr. Schmelkin
reported
that the task force was asked to study alternative
delivery methods
for CPE such as bulletin boards and Internet chat
rooms. He stated
that at the most recent meeting only the two student
task force members were present for a conference call.
He shared their findings that two current providers
of online CPE were eMind and Blackboard. A memorandum
has been sent to the other task force requesting them
to submit reports on their findings.
|
| 4)
Policy for Complimentary Guests at FAE Conferences |
The
Trustees discussed the issue of developing a policy
to allow
for complimentary guests at FAE conferences. It was
noted that
since there was no uniform policy governing such practices,
the
Trustees should establish one. Following discussion,
a motion was
made by Jeffrey Hoops that only a member of a panel
or speaker
at a FAE conference who is a government official may
invite one guest. The motion was seconded by Mr. Riley
and unanimously carried by all.
|
| 5)
Pricing Policy for Chapter Originated CPE Courses |
President
Newman-Limata asked Mr. Schmelkin to give a
Chapter Originated background report on the pricing
of chapter programs. He reported that the statewide
pricing for chapter programs has been
$75 for a 4-hour program (1/2 day); $150 for an 8-hour
program,
and chapter sets their own fees for programs 1-3 hours.
Recently,
some chapters have identified outside sponsors to
cover some expenses and venues at lower costs. Several
chapters requested a price lower than the statewide
pricing. It was reported that the Westchester Chapter
requested a lower price; $125 as a regular price with
an early bird discount price of $99, with the proviso
that they seek program sponsors to cover $4,000 to
supplement the standard full day price. Mr. Schmelkin
explained that preliminary analysis resulted in average
overhead of $168 per hour to administer chapter half
and full-day programs.
President
Newman-Limata then welcomed the chapter presidents
on conference call to participate in the discussion
on chapter program pricing. The following chapter
presidents participated by conference call: Ann Cohen
of Buffalo, Robert Ecker of Westchester, Steven Kaplan
of Rockland, and Robert Sypolt of Queens. Each chapter
representative voiced their concerns over the current
pricing structure. Following discussion, the Trustees
recommended that going forward a task force be established
to study the overhead projection and allocation, thereby
setting an overhead per participant charge for chapter
four and eight-hour programs. It was suggested that
the Vice President of Chapters, the FAE Trustees’
Secretary and Treasurer, and representatives from
the chapters serve on the task force. It was concluded
that, with the exception of the Westchester Chapter
pre-approved reduced registration fee, all other chapters
will continue to charge the current standard registration
fee of $150 for full day chapter conferences until
a new policy is established. |
| 6)
New Business --
a.
FAE University |
FAE
Trustee Jeffrey Hoops proposed that the FAE considers
the
creation of a “FAE University” that would
be a 3-day long, 24-hour CPE program featuring a multi-curriculum
of two half-day
sessions scheduled in 3 or 4 central locations across
the state
during the summer months. Mr. Hoops added that the proposal
is
similar to that of the AICPA Federal Tax 3-day program.
Mr.
Hoops made the following suggestions: 1) the proposed
program
could be scheduled in an academic setting or local hotels;
2) the
possibility of consolidating current FAE low-performing
programs;
and 3) the program’s potential to attract sponsors
thereby reducing
the cost to the FAE. The
Trustees discussed the merits of the proposal, which
presents
the opportunity to build relationships with major
universities
across the state. Following discussion, it was recommended
that
the staff conduct a cost and benefit analysis of the
proposal.
|
| b.
Value Pricing Seminar |
President
Newman-Limata reported that Society member Mark
Koziel submitted a proposal for consideration on FAE
partnering
with VeraSage Institute’s Value Pricing seminars.
Mr. Schmelkin
gave a background report of a similar program called
Boot Camp, begun years ago by the California CPE Foundation.
Following discussion, the Trustees recommended that
more study on the concept of FAE partnering with external
seminar providers is needed.
|
| 7)
Audit Committee Report |
President
Newman-Limata asked Julie Floch, participating by
conference call, to give the Audit Committee Report
on the FAE
consolidated financial statements for the year ended
May 31, 2002
and management letter. Following review and discussion,
President Newman-Limata thanked Ms. Floch for her report.
A
motion was made to accept the financial report as it
related to the
FAE Operation. The motion was unanimously passed.
|
| 8)
Policy on Conflict Interest |
President
Newman-Limata suggested that in before action
by the Society’s Board of Directors’ , she
is recommending that the consideration of adopting a
conflict-of- interest policy be deferred until the FAE
Trustees have had an opportunity to review and discuss
the proposal
further. In addition, she suggested that a task force
should study the policy to include the issue of committee
members and other Society leaders being paid to teach
for the FAE.
|
| 9)
FAE Operations |
President
Newman-Limata asked Alan Schmelkin to give a report
on FAE Operations. Mr. Schmelkin reported that, as a
result of
previous FAE Trustees’ recommendations, several
changes were made in the scheduling, programming and
operations of seminar and conference offerings. Specifically,
the core curriculum of seminar offerings were scheduled
in all chapter locations or areas within close proximity
to the chapters. Marginal courses were not rescheduled.
The actual number of sessions ran between June 1, 2002
and August 31, 2002 were 320 out of 348 budgeted.
New
registration policies regarding cancellations, walk-ins,
and transfers were instituted, advertised and enforced.
Seminars were ran with a minimum of 8 registrants
and those offerings that did not meet the minimum
registration were cancelled two weeks in advance of
the presentation date after analyzing various cost
factors. In addition, a system of notifying chapter
officers of seminars in jeopardy of canceling due
to low registration was implemented.
Mr.
Schmelkin gave a prior two-year comparative analysis
of statewide versus chapter provided CPE attendance.
The Trustees review statistical data from CPE years
at 5/31/2001 and 5/31/2002. The report showed that
total registrations for those two years combined were
97.3% attendance at FAE full day events versus a 2.7%
attendance at chapter full day events.
Executive
Director Louis Grumet announced that FAE will be hiring
a staff member to work on curriculum development and
in-firm sales.
|
| 10)
Future Meeting Dates |
President
Newman-Limata announced the following future
meeting dates:
Monday,
December 16, 2002 at 10:00am
Wednesday, January 15, 2003 at 10:00am
|
| 11)
Adjournment |
President
Newman-Limata asked if there was any further business
to be addressed at the meeting. There being none, the
meeting
adjourned at 4:45pm.
|
Respectfully submitted,
Jeffrey R. Hoops, Secretary |
|
|