| |
|
Governance
| MINUTES
OF: |
Foundation
for Accounting Education Trustees |
| DATE
OF MEETING: |
Tuesday,
July 12, 2005 |
| LOCATION: |
Sagamore
Resort
Bolton Landing, Lake George, New York |
| TIME
MEETING CONVENED: |
12:30
p.m. |
| TIME
MEETING ADJOURNED: |
2:36 p.m. |
| PRESIDING
OFFICER: |
Arthur
Bloom, President |
| MEMBERS
PRESENT: |
Gail
M. Kinsella, President-Elect
Peter K. Maier, Secretary
Scott J. Jaffee, Treasurer
D. Edward Martin*
Jeffrey M. Rosenbaum
Louis Grumet, Executive Director
|
| MEMBERS
ABSENT: |
Alan
T. Frankel
Elliot L. Hendler
Franco Strangis
|
| STAFF
PRESENT: |
Adam
Cheung
Alan Schmelkin
Monte Kaplan
William Pape
Paul L. Sinegal
James A. Woehlke
|
*Participated by phone
Minutes
| 0)
Call to Order |
The
Trustees convened the meeting at 12:30 p.m. and unanimously
designated Mr. Bloom acting chair. Mr. Bloom then appointed
Mr. Maier acting Secretary.
|
| 1)
Approval of Minutes of FAE Board of Trustees May 17,
2005, Meeting
|
Mr.
Bloom asked if there were any changes to the minutes
of the FAE Board of Trustees May 17 2005, meeting. There
being none, Mr. Rosenbaum moved to approve the minutes
of the May 17, 2005, meeting and Ms. Kinsella seconded
the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Mr. Martin,
who had not yet joined the meeting, did not participate
in the vote.
|
|
2) Election of FAE Officers |
Mr.
Bloom called upon Mr. Woehlke to summarize the recent
governance changes affecting the appointment of FAE’s
officers. Mr. Woehlke stated that as of the fiscal year
commencing June 1, 2005, FAE’s officers would
no longer be automatically appointed by virtue of their
respective NYSSCPA officer positions. Instead, FAE officers
would be elected by the Trustees themselves from among
their number, pursuant to new FAE bylaws (effective
June 1, 2005) which provide for the following elected
offices:
-
President
- President-Elect
- Secretary
- Treasurer
Mr.
Woehlke noted that the Trustees would not normally elect
FAE’s President outright under the new bylaws,
but instead elect a President-Elect to automatically
assume FAE’s presidency in the succeeding year.
Nevertheless, in this first year under the new bylaws,
since there was no President-Elect from the previous
year, the trustees would need to select a president.
Mr.
Woehlke reminded all present that the Trustees serve
three-year terms, while officers serve one-year terms;
therefore, the President-Elect could only assume the
FAE Presidency in the succeeding year if he or she were
still a Trustee at that time. Accordingly, Mr. Woehlke
suggested that the Trustees select a President-Elect
who was currently in his or her first or second year
on the Board of Trustees. The Trustees by consensus
agreed with this approach.
Mr.
Bloom opened the floor to nominations for the FAE Presidency,
and Ms. Kinsella nominated Mr. Bloom. Mr. Bloom accepted
the nomination. There being no further nominations,
Ms. Kinsella moved to close the nominations, and Mr.
Jaffee seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously
and nominations were closed. Upon a duly-held election,
the Trustees unanimously elected Mr. Bloom as FAE President.
Mr. Martin, who had not yet joined the meeting, did
not participate in the vote.
President
Bloom then opened the floor to nominations for FAE President-Elect.
Mr. Maier nominated Ms. Kinsella, who accepted the nomination.
There being no further nominations, Mr. Maier moved
to close the nominations and Mr. Jaffee seconded the
motion. The motion passed unanimously and nominations
were closed. Upon a duly-held election, Ms. Kinsella
was unanimously elected President-Elect. Mr. Martin,
who had not yet joined the meeting, did not participate
in the vote.
President
Bloom opened the floor to nominations for Secretary,
and then nominated Mr. Maier. Mr. Maier accepted the
nomination. There being no further nominations, President
Bloom moved to close nominations, and Ms. Kinsella seconded
the motion. The motion passed unanimously and nominations
were closed. Upon a duly-held election, Mr. Maier was
unanimously elected Secretary. Mr. Martin, who had not
yet joined the meeting, did not participate in the vote.
President
Bloom opened the floor to nominations for Treasurer,
and then nominated Mr. Jaffee. Mr. Jaffee accepted the
nomination. There being no further nominations, President
Bloom moved to close nominations, and Ms. Kinsella seconded
the motion. The motion passed unanimously and nominations
were closed. Upon a duly-held election, Mr. Jaffee was
unanimously elected Treasurer. Mr. Martin, who had not
yet joined the meeting, did not participate in the vote.
|
| 3)
Draft Financial Statements for 12-month Fiscal Year
ended May 31, 2005
|
Mr.
Cheung reviewed the financial statements for the 12-month
fiscal year ended May 31, 2005, noting that FAE had
a strong year. Mr. Cheung reported that FAE’s
budgeted inter-company contribution from the NYSSCPA
of approximately $533,000 had been utilized only to
the extent of $440,000, and, therefore, FAE was $93,000
under budget.
A
Trustee asked for an explanation of a bad debt expense
which appeared in the statements. Mr. Schmelkin explained
that a small number of FAE course takers do not ultimately
pay for the course. He covered several of the reasons
why this occurs including claims made at the registration
desk that a firm has sent a check in the mail. He noted
that although staff does its best to police fraudulent
claims and collect outstanding balances, a small number
of uncollected balances are budgeted under the category
of bad debt expenses.
|
| 4)
FAE Affiliation Agreement action by NYSSCPA Board of Directors |
President
Bloom asked Mr. Woehlke to provide background on the draft
intercompany affiliation agreement between the NYSSCPA
and FAE. Mr. Woehlke noted that the proposed agreement
had been in development for some time to formally document
the obligations each company owes to the other, including
(a) the approaches currently used to allocate expenses
between FAE and the Society; (b) the programs FAE co-sponsors
with the Society or administers for the Society; and (c)
the governance relationship between the two organizations,
including a prohibition on FAE from changing its bylaws
to impede NYSSCPA participation in FAE’s governance
structure. He stated that such an agreement is considered
a best practice for educational foundations and their
affiliated professional societies, and that it had been
reviewed by Howe & Hutton, the Society’s outside
counsel.
Mr.
Woehlke reported that the FAE Trustees had unanimously
approved a prior draft of the Affiliation Agreement
in May 2005; however, the NYSSCPA Executive Committee
subsequently recommended an amendment to the FAE-approved
draft whereby the agreement would run for five years
without an automatic renewal term. The NYSSCPA Board
then approved the amended draft at a meeting earlier
in the day.
A
Trustee asked if there was an exclusivity clause in
the agreement whereby FAE would be the exclusive provider
of CPE for Society members. Mr. Schmelkin responded
that there was no such clause because FAE purchases
a percentage of its courses and materials from other
CPE providers such as the AICPA.
Ms.
Kinsella moved that the Affiliation Agreement between
NYSSCPA and FAE be approved as amended by the NYSSCPA,
and that the FAE President be authorized and directed
to execute the agreement on behalf of FAE. Mr. Maier
seconded the motion. Following discussion, the motion
passed unanimously.
|
| 5)
COAP |
Mr.
Pape, Member Relations Director, gave an overview of the
Career Opportunities in the Accounting Profession (COAP)
program, noting that the program is a five-day summer
program for high school juniors from minority groups historically
underrepresented in the CPA profession. He stated that
the COAP program is held at several college campuses across
New York State which provides students an invaluable preview
of college life.
In response
to a question, Mr. Cheung stated that the 2005 programs
cost approximately $168,000, and that $94,000 and $88,000
had been applied to the program through fundraising
efforts in the last two years respectively. Mr. Grumet
announced that the program would be held in Buffalo
for the first time in the coming year, and that several
additional locations were being considered.
Ms.
Kinsella spoke highly regarding her experiences with
the Syracuse COAP program and encouraged the Trustees
to attend a COAP program session or volunteer their
time in program planning to see first hand how rewarding
the program is for all involved. The Trustees by consensus
requested that the minutes reflect their unanimous enthusiasm
and support for the COAP program.
|
| 6)
Scholarship Program |
Mr.
Grumet reminded the Trustees that per its actions at
a November 15, 2004 meeting, the implementation of a
new FAE scholarship program structure would take effect
as of the 2006 school year, with the existing structure
remaining in force throughout the 2005 school year.
He noted that the 2005-2006 FAE Trustees would be responsible
for planning towards a 2006 implementation date, including
appointing a scholarship program oversight committee.
|
| 7)
Fundraising |
Mr.
Grumet announced that the commemorative journal for
the annual NYSSCPA Board dinner raised approximately
$88,000 in advertising revenue, all going toward funding
of the COAP Program.
|
| 8)
Combination of Benevolent and Scholarship Funds |
Mr.
Grumet provided background on a proposal to combine the
NYSSCPA Benevolent Fund and FAE. Mr. Woehlke noted that
outside counsel recommended that before such a merger
were undertaken, the FAE certificate of incorporation
should be amended to clarify FAE’s existing purpose.
To this end, the FAE trustees had voted to amend its corporate
purpose at their May 2005 meeting. The process of filing
the amendment would proceed now that FAE had its 2005-2006
officers in place. |
| 9)
Proposal for Curriculum Committee |
Mr.
Schmelkin gave an overview of how FAE currently develops
its educational calendar and budget, and noted that FAE
programming is typically approved by the Board of Trustees
through the budgetary process. The Trustees then discussed
whether a curriculum committee would be helpful to the
current process. During the discussion, several CPE program
ideas were suggested, including industry courses on COBRA
letters and other issues that affect a CFO in a human
resources role. Messrs. Bloom and Jaffee then agreed to
serve on a curriculum committee. Mr.
Schmelkin then reviewed timing issues with respect to
program planning, noting that FAE typically reviews
the summer 2005 CPE season and decides whether to continue
the POP program during its September Trustees meeting.
He noted that the September meeting would be instrumental
in a discussion of curriculum committee plans for the
ensuing year, and suggested that Messrs. Bloom and Jaffee
meet with Monte Kaplan and himself by conference call
in October to further discuss specific curriculum issues.
The Trustees by consensus agreed with this approach.
|
| 10)
Meeting Dates 2005-06 |
After
a brief discussion, Mr. Schmelkin agreed to solicit available
dates and times from the Trustees for future 2005-2006
Trustee meetings. |
| 11)
Other matters |
i)
Designation of FAE Representative to Investment and
Finance Committees
After
a brief discussion, President Bloom appointed Mr. Jaffee
as FAE’s representative to both the NYSSCPA Finance
Committee and Investment Committee.
ii)
FAE Monthly Contract Report
In
response to a question regarding the monthly FAE contract
report, Mr. Woehlke explained that the Trustees had
passed a contract approval policy which directed staff
to issue such a monthly report.
iii)
Bank Signatories
Ms.
Kinsella made the following resolution regarding signature
authority over FAE’s bank accounts. Mr. Martin
seconded.
RESOLVED, that the following persons are hereby appointed
to serve as authorized signatories on all banking and
investment accounts of the Foundation for Accounting
Education Inc.:
Arthur
Bloom
Gail M. Kinsella
Peter K. Maier
Scott J. Jaffee
Louis Grumet
Alan Schmelkin
Robert H. Colson
James A. Woehlke
Joanne S. Barry
Dennis M. O’Leary
RESOLVED,
FURTHER, that two signatures are required on every
check and any check over $10,000 requires one of the
signatures to be either Mr. Bloom or Mr. Jaffee;
RESOLVED,
FURTHER, that in the event Messrs. Bloom and Jaffee
are both unavailable to sign any check over $10,000,
Messrs. Martin and Frankel shall be authorized to
serve as backup signatories on such checks; and
RESOLVED,
FURTHER, that the officers of the Foundation for Accounting
Education, Inc. and the staff of the New York State
Society of Certified Public Accountants are hereby
authorized and directed to execute and deliver any
documentation required to carry out the intent of
this resolution.
Following
discussion, the resolution was unanimously adopted.
|
| 12)
Adjournment |
There being no further business, Ms. Kinsella moved to
adjourn the meeting, and Mr. Jaffee seconded the motion.
The meeting adjourned at 2:36 p.m. Mr. Martin did not
participate in the vote. |
Respectfully submitted,
Peter K. Maier, Secretary |
|
|