| |
|
Governance
| MINUTES
OF: |
FAE
Board of Trustees Meeting |
| DATE
OF MEETING: |
Tuesday,
November 17, 2003 |
| LOCATION: |
via
Conference Call |
| TIME
MEETING CONVENED: |
3:06.pm. |
| TIME
MEETING ADJOURNED: |
4:39 p.m. |
| PRESIDING
OFFICER: |
Jo
Ann Golden, President |
| MEMBERS
PRESENT: |
Jeffery
R, Hoops, President-Elect
Jeffrey M. Rosenbaum
John J. Kearney, Secretary
Thomas E. Riley
Illene L. Persoff
Louis Grumet, Executive Director |
| MEMBERS
EXCUSED: |
Sharon
Sabba Fierstein
Franco Strangis |
| MEMBER
ABSENT: |
Ronald Benjamin |
| STAFF
PRESENT: |
Lynn
T. Chambers
Alan Schmelkin
David Cho
James A. Woehlke
Monte Kaplan
|
Minutes
| 0)
Call to Order |
President
Golden called the meeting to order at 3:06.pm.
|
| 1)
Review of Financial Statements
|
Ms.
Chambers briefed the committee on details of the financial
statements for the period ending October 31, 2003.
Cash equivalents were $3.7 million, which was noted
to be $700K over last year and $1 million over the
year before. Revenue was $48K less than budgeted because,
while realized and unrealized gain was $33K, only
$5,000 was received from chapter CPE revenue, compared
to the $42K budgeted, and rental income was down $43K
from the budgeted figures because of the loss of several
customers. Total expenses were under budget for each
of the three goals. The total expenses of the Advocacy
Goal were under budget by $86K, and the total expenses
of the Professional Competency Goal were under budget
by $316K.
|
| 2)
Discussion of Scholarship Fund – Benevolent
Fund |
Ms. Golden briefed the committee on the current benevolent
fund proposal to change its purpose to provide scholarships
and made the proposal that FAE transfer the funds
in its Scholarship Fund to the new organization so
scholarships can be more effectively administered
by one organization dedicated to that purpose.
Mr.
Riley raised concern over transferring assets to an
unrelated non-profit entity, not under the control
of the Trustees. Mr. Riley moved and Ms. Persoff seconded
that FAE investigate how to best transfer the assets
of its scholarship fund to continue its benefit and
insulate FAE from liability. The motion passed unanimously.
|
| 3)
Course Development for 2004-05
|
a.
Industry Topics
Mr.
Schmelkin updated the Trustees on the course development
in Industry topics. Citing the feeling that FAE has
not done enough to serve the industry members, and
the pending legislation in Albany that may require
CPAs in industry to take CPE, Mr. Schmelkin said there
is additional impetus to take a look at industry curriculum
for this year. Since Ms. Fierstein and Mr. Strangis
were not in attendance, Mr. Kaplan briefed the Trustees
on the work of the committee on CPE curriculum for
industry. The committee identified four basic areas:
Personal Attributes, Leadership Qualities, Broad Business
Perspective, and Functional Specialties. Mr. Schmelkin
informed the Trustees that based on the areas identified
by the committee, FAE is developing courses in these
four competency areas.
Mr.
Schmelkin also noted that the successful September
SEC conference sold out at 255 people, about 100 ahead
of budget. . Mr. Schmelkin predicted that based on
the strength of the conference, along with a favorable
variance as of August 31, 2003, that FAE is positioned
well for the balance of the year.
b.
Other Topic – FAE Office Move
Ms.
Golden noted that the NYSSCPA Board of Directors has
voted to move NYSSCPA’s offices in 2004 to a
new location. Mr. Riley moved, Mr. Hoops seconded
that FAE relocate its offices to the same site. The
motion passed unanimously.
Mr.
Grumet update the Trustees that the location at the
top of the list being considered is at 34th Street
and Park Avenue, and that FAE should be settled in
its new office space by the start of the 2004 summer
CPE season.
|
| 4)
FAE Support for Chapter CPE Events |
Mr.
Schmelkin informed the committee that certain chapters
have contracted directly with some commercial CPE
providers and speakers who go through firms in the
chapter areas to offer non-FAE, non-chapter CPE courses.
Mr. Schmelkin is concerned about selective cherry-picking
of FAE’s statewide market, creating significant
disparate pricing between FAE and the chapters. He
urged the Trustees to take a stand that chapter’s
cannot have outside commercial vendors. Thee Board
agreed with the position and directed Mr. Schmelkin
to develop a written policy for FAE on the subject,
which the Trustees will examine and vote upon. |
5)
POP Program Update
|
Ms.
Golden noted that many managing partners of CPA firms
are not aware of the POP Firm or Company booklets,
and that letters will be sent to managing partners
or CPE coordinators at CPA firms in New York.
|
6)
Other Matters
|
a)
Conflict of Interest Policy
Mr.
Woehlke briefed the Trustees on the Conflict of Interest
Policy recommended by the NYSSCPA Board task force
to develop policies chaired by Mr. Kearney.
Mr.
Riley moved and Mr. Hoops seconded a motion to ratify
the Conflict of Interest Policy. The Trustees voted
unanimously in favor of ratifying the policy.
|
| 7)
Schedule of Future Meeting Dates |
The
Trustees scheduled their next meeting for December 16,
2003 at 10:00 AM. |
| 8)
Adjournment |
Having
no further business, on a motion by Mr. Riley, seconded
by Mr. Kearney, the Trustees adjourned the conference
call at 4:39 p.m. |
Respectfully submitted,
John
J. Kearney, Secretary |
|
|