Home | Join | Site Map
 
Search

About Us
Society Overview
Membership Center
Chapters
Committees
Governance
NYSSCPA Audit Committee Minutes
NYSSCPA Board of Directors Minutes
NYSSCPA Executive Committee Minutes
NYSSCPA Finance Committee Minutes
FAE Finance Committee Minutes
FAE Trustees Committee Minutes
Strategic Plan
Society Jobs
Society Officers
Press Room
Staff Directory


 

Governance

Minutes of:

Executive Committee Meeting

Date & Time:

Tuesday, March 5, 2002, 2:10 p.m. to 4:45 p.m.

Location:

NYSSCPA Offices, 530 Fifth Avenue

Presiding Officer:

Nancy Newman-Limata, President

Executive Committee Members Present:

Jo Ann Golden, President-Elect
G. William Hatfield, Vice President*
Kevin J. McCoy, Vice President
Frank J. Aquilino, Treasurer
Sharon Sabba Fierstein, Secretary*

* participated via telephone

Arthur Bloom
Ian M. Nelson
Stephen F. Langowski
Carol C. Lapidus
Louis Grumet, Executive Director

Executive Committee Member Absent:

Peter H. Frank

 

Staff Present:

Joanne S. Barry
Lynn Chambers
Robert H. Colson
Ernest J. Markezin
Dennis M. O’Leary

William Pape
Alan Schmelkin
Paul L. Sinegal
James A. Woehlke

 

M I N U T E S

02 – D – 00

Call to Order

Ms. Newman-Limata called the meeting to order at 2:10 p.m.

02 – D – 01

Minutes

The minutes of the last three Executive Committee meetings were discussed.

Ms. Newman-Limata asked if there were changes to the January 29, 2002 conference call minutes, which had been distributed with the March 5 Agenda. There being none, she declared them approved as written.

Ms. Newman-Limata asked if there were any changes to the February 12, 2002 minutes. Mr. Woehlke noted that senior staff suggested that in the President’s Report, section "b", the estimated amount the Society spent on the World Trade Center Recovery Program should be changed from $20,000 to $24,000. Ms. Newman-Limata asked that the minutes be further amended to reflect the fact that Society staff estimated this figure, not herself.

In the Executive Director’s Report, Section "a", the number of chapters desiring to publish their newsletter in The Trusted Professional was corrected from 12 to 13, to reflect the inclusion of the Rochester Chapter.

In the Report of the Finance Committee, sections "a" and "b", the applicable dates of both FAE’s and NYSSCPA’s Financial Statements should be January 31, 2002, not December 31, 2001, and all references to a seven-month period should be changed to an eight-month period. Also, in section "a", the words "from FAE" should be changed to "in the Foundation."

Ms. Newman-Limata asked if there were any objections to these suggested changes. There being none, she declared the minutes approved with the revisions.

Ms. Newman-Limata asked if there were any proposed changes to the minutes of the February 22, 2002 conference call. There being none, she declared the minutes approved as written.

A brief discussion ensued with respect to the distribution of Executive Committee meeting materials. Following the discussion, staff was directed to use second day priority mail rather than express mail for last-minute mailings and to delete the "notes" pages from the agenda materials.

02 – D – 02

President’s Report

  1. Senate Hearings

    Ms. Newman-Limata briefed the Committee regarding the second set of hearings before the New York State Senate Higher Education Committee, held on February 26. She noted in particular the testimony of former NYSSCPA President Marilyn Pendergast, current NYSSCPA Vice President Kevin J. McCoy and Board member Katharine Doran, who testified in their individual capacities.
  2. Ms. Newman-Limata noted that the hearings stressed the need to slow the process down. She noted that many terms in the proposed legislation, such as "business consulting", are not well defined. She advised that two approaches had been proposed to address this: a "laundry list" of services and a list of broad principles (the "principle-based" approach).

    Ms. Newman-Limata said that Messrs. O’Leary and Colson drafted a set of proposed principles for submission to the New York State legislative leadership. A copy of the proposed principles was distributed to Executive Committee members. Mr. Grumet noted that the proposed principles are meant as a guide for the legislature.

    A discussion ensued regarding whether the principle-based or the "laundry-list" approach is the best way to proceed. Ms. Newman-Limata expressed concern over who would be empowered to interpret or judge an accountant’s acts under any resulting legislation, noting that the answers to this question may compel preference for one approach over another.

    Mr. Grumet advised the committee that the Senate will conduct roundtable sessions on Wednesday, March 13 and will want to know where the Society stands. [The March 13 roundtable was subsequently changed to March 20.] He encouraged the Executive Committee to decide which approach should be used.

    Ms. Newman-Limata noted that the Executive Committee, which just received the proposed principles, should be given an opportunity to review the principles before a decision is made. She suggested the committee reconvene by telephone conference to discuss which approach should be taken.

    After a brief discussion, the committee agreed to reconvene by telephone conference on Friday, March 8, 2002 at 9:00 a.m. for this purpose.

  3. NYSSCPA Comment Letters
  4. Ms. Newman-Limata noted that NYSSCPA Comment Letters continue to provide thoughtful guidance. Appended to the Agenda was a letter dated February 19, 2002 from Nancy Newman-Limata to Ms. Amy Pfalzgraf, Office of the Associate Chief Counsel (Income Tax and Accounting), Internal Revenue Service.

  5. Relations with State Board of Accountancy
  6. Mr. McCoy noted that a special meeting of the State Board for Public Accountancy was called to discuss proposed legislation. He said that the Enron bankruptcy has served as an awakening for the Education Department, which oversees the State Board.

    Mr. McCoy indicated that the meeting produced no conclusions with respect to the legislation, but added that there was a level of consistency on issues such as scope of practice and peer review, among others.

    He also said that State Board Executive Secretary, Daniel J. Dustin, emphasized that the New York State Education Department regulates CPAs, not the State Board, which merely acts in an advisory capacity to the SED.

    Mr. O’Leary noted that the Society might have more allies on the State Board than previously. He added that the State Board did not reach consensus on such issues as auditor rotation and non-licensees. Mr. O’Leary also announced that there will be an article published in the next issue of The Trusted Professional on whether the State Education Department represents the advice of the State Board of Accountancy, or whether it acts independently of the State Board.

    Ms. Newman-Limata added that while the Society has improved its relationship with the State Board, its relationship with the Education Department has not shown similar progress.

  7. Cooperation with SSNI and SSLLC

Ms. Newman-Limata noted CPA2Biz’s recent acquisition of a California-based web services provider, Rivio. Rivio’s former CEO is now responsible for overseeing the day-to-day operations of CPA2Biz.

A discussion ensued with respect to the AICPA’s control over the internet portal and its finances. Although it was stated that the AICPA continues to own publication licenses, several members expressed concern over the AICPA’s retention of control over the portal and its financial stake in it. Ms. Newman-Limata said that these are legitimate concerns, which should be raised at the next AICPA regional meeting, to be held March 19 – 21.

Ms. Newman-Limata stressed the need to look at NYSSCPA key services in comparison to the AICPA. She noted that the Society should strive to offer services, especially insurance, on a level consistent with the AICPA in order to better serve the members.

02 – D – 03

Report of the Finance Committee

Ms. Newman-Limata asked Ms. Chambers to present the report of the Finance Committee.

 

Ms. Newman-Limata reminded the committee of the Board’s directive to underwrite a loss from FAE up to the extent of $300,000 and noted that the current budget reflected a deficit from FAE of $594,500.

Mr. Schmelkin noted that the Finance Committee thoroughly considered the Executive Committee’s direction in good faith before arriving at $594,500, which was significantly lower than the deficit previously discussed with the Executive Committee. He noted that the FAE Trustees felt that the ramifications of Enron’s bankruptcy, in conjunction with more targeted marketing of FAE’s conferences and seminars, strongly suggests a higher anticipated attendance rate, thus increasing anticipated revenue by 10 percent. Mr. Schmelkin added that two committees, the Government Accounting and Financial Accounting Standards Committees, would run a conference specifically tied to the issues raised by the Enron matter.

Mr. Schmelkin further stated that under the contract the Society and FAE have with E-Mind (formerly Yipinet) for online CPE, FAE is guaranteed a payment of approximately $150,000 in October 2002, the end of the current contract term. He noted that this amount has been included in FAE’s budget.

Mr. Schmelkin also said that the FAE Trustees reinstated a registration fee for attendance at committee-sponsored Evening Technical Sessions, the anticipated revenue of which was calculated to be $30,000. FAE also instituted a $25 surcharge for course walk-ins and a $25 fee for cancellations within two weeks of a course. Mr. Schmelkin indicated that these new policies are being well publicized in media, including the Society’s website and print publications.

Mr. Schmelkin noted that when taking these factors into consideration, anticipated FAE revenue is significantly more favorable than initially reported to the Executive Committee. He referred members to the newly amended budget report for a full accounting of the current projections.

A committee member asked whether FAE could realistically recapture 10 percent of the revenue as anticipated in the current budget. Ms. Chambers noted that staff had been even more optimistic regarding this figure, but the FAE Trustees were more conservative and thus held the estimate firm at 10 percent.

Mr. Schmelkin reviewed some of the trends in course attendance and revenue from prior years, pointing out that although there is not a linear progression, the FAE Trustees looked carefully at those programs that attracted the most people and revenue.

Ms. Chambers drew Executive Committee attention to several items such as staff timesheets and a savings of $25,000 on committee breakfasts, which will no longer be provided. Mr. Grumet noted that the response from committee chairs to the change in the provision of food to committees has been very positive. He indicated that several chairs volunteered to buy their committee’s refreshments out of their own pockets.

Mr. Schmelkin reported that the Society is in the process of negotiating a contract with Quality Inn Hotel, located on 46th Street between 5th and 6th Avenues. The contract would provide accommodations for Society and FAE guests and leadership at a standard rate of $109 per night. Mr. Schmelkin noted that the hotel provides standard amenities, clean rooms, a safe and well-trafficked neighborhood, and is conveniently located near the Society’s offices. Mr. Grumet added that the proposed budget assumes that once the contract is finalized, lodging in the Quality Inn Hotel would be required for both Society and FAE, except on certain contracted "black-out" dates.

Ms. Chambers said that $85,000 in savings was identified in the budget when several chapters opted to produce their newsletters electronically and in The Trusted Professional, thus saving postage and printing costs.

A committee member asked how the additional staff cuts anticipated by the budget would affect the quality of services and staff morale. Mr. Grumet said that eleven positions, or roughly 10 percent of the staff, have already been eliminated this fiscal year. He advised the committee that the proposed budget assumes two additional cutbacks. He said that staff overall is working very hard and will be held more accountable as a result of the cuts. He added that a time clock would be installed to monitor staff time, overtime will require executive director pre-approval, and requests for temporary help will be largely curtailed. A brief discussion ensued with respect to staff issues; however, several members cautioned their colleagues against micro-managing.

A discussion then ensued with respect to meeting costs, with a member suggesting the increased use of "virtual meetings" as a way to save costs. Mr. Grumet added that the Society would also look at eliminating off-site meeting expenses, including costs associated with off-site board meetings.

A committee member expressed the view that the budget appears to represent an even-handed, fair and deliberative process, but added that accountability should be strictly enforced and measured.

Ms. Fierstein then moved to recommend to the Board of Directors the approval of the proposed 2002-2003 NYSSCPA/FAE budget, and Mr. Langowski seconded. Following discussion, the motion was approved unanimously.

02 – D – 04

Rental of Society Office Space

It was noted that the Society has entered into an agreement with a non-Society-related business for office space at the Society’s headquarters. Mr. Schmelkin noted that the group consists of retired lawyers. Under the agreement, the group has limited access to Society copy machines, faxes and a phone line.

Several members expressed concern over the idea of renting space to non-Society-related entities due to confidentiality and security issues, and potential conflicts with the Society’s mission and purpose. Some members reminded the group that other entities already rent Society classrooms on a regular basis. Others noted, however, that the classrooms are physically separate from Society staff offices. After a brief discussion, the committee reached the consensus that all renting of office space should cease until a discrete policy can be developed by the Executive Committee regarding the issue.

A discussion then ensued regarding what to do about the current agreement. Mr. Schmelkin noted that the current agreement runs on a month-to-month basis and could be terminated with one month’s notice. After a brief discussion regarding whether and when to terminate the agreement, the committee consented to allow the current agreement to continue, for a period of six months.

Mr. Grumet noted that the Society’s current office lease will end in 2004, and the Real Estate Task Force is reviewing options for a new location. He noted that space has been identified on Madison Avenue and 38th Street; however, the task force recommended that a broker be hired to assist in locating additional options. Ms. Newman-Limata expressed the need to have an Executive Committee member participate in that process. By consensus, the Executive Committee approved the issuance of the RFP to identify a broker.

 

 

02 – D – 05

Adjournment

There being no further business, Mr. Nelson moved to adjourn the meeting, and Ms. Fierstein seconded. All being in favor of the motion, the meeting adjourned at 4:45 p.m.

Respectfully submitted,

Sharon Sabba Fierstein,

Secretary


Home
| About Us | Continuing Education | Future CPAs | Government Affairs | Professional Resources | Publications | Sound Advice | Tax Resources

Chapters | Committees | Member Center | Events Calendar | Classifieds | Careers | E-zine Subscriptions | The Trusted Professional | The CPA Journal



Search | Site Map | Become a Member | Jobs | Press Room | Contact Us | Feedback

©1997 - 2009 New York State Society of Certified Public Accountants. Legal Notices